AuthoredUp vs Phantomwriter
AuthoredUp
- Platform: LinkedIn only
- Best For: Content creation and analytics
- Strength: Powerful editor and historical post insights
- Users: 2,011 professionals
Starting at $12.46/month
Phantomwriter
- Platform: LinkedIn only
- Best For: AI automation and ghostwriting
- Strength: Autopilot posting and undetectable AI content
- Users: Not specified
Starting at $49/month
Table of Contents
At a Glance
Platform Support
| Feature | AuthoredUp | Phantomwriter |
|---|---|---|
| ✓ Deep integration via Chrome extension and multi-profile support | ✓ Focused on LinkedIn with AI-optimized posting | |
| Multi-platform support | ✗ LinkedIn-exclusive | ✗ LinkedIn-exclusive |
| Chrome extension | ✓ Full editor and preview inside LinkedIn | ✗ Web-based, no extension mentioned |
Content Creation
| Feature | AuthoredUp | Phantomwriter |
|---|---|---|
| Rich text editor | ✓ Supports bold, italics, bullets, emojis, live preview | ✗ AI-generated text, no manual formatting editor |
| AI post generation | ✗ No native AI, relies on templates and user input | ✓ AI ghostwriter for full posts, undetectable by AI detectors |
| Drafts and snippets | ✓ Unlimited drafts, snippets, and reusable blocks | ✗ Focus on generation, no draft management |
| Templates and hooks | ✓ 300+ hooks, endings, CTA templates | ✓ Tailored post ideas based on audience analysis |
| Idea generation | ✗ Inspiration via templates and historical posts | ✓ Audience analysis for industry-specific ideas |
| Unlimited regeneration | ✗ Manual editing only | ✓ Regenerate posts unlimited times |
| Multi-language support | ✗ English-focused | ✓ Any language support |
| Lead magnet creator | ✗ No built-in | ✓ Tools for audience capture |
Scheduling & Automation
| Feature | AuthoredUp | Phantomwriter |
|---|---|---|
| Content calendar | ✓ Centralized calendar for published and scheduled posts | ✓ Calendar for managing and scheduling AI-generated posts |
| Autopilot scheduling | ✗ Manual scheduling | ✓ Autopilot mode for consistent posting |
| Post reuse | ✓ 1-click reuse from historical content | ✗ Regeneration but no historical reuse |
Analytics & Reporting
| Feature | AuthoredUp | Phantomwriter |
|---|---|---|
| Post analytics | ✓ Impressions, engagement, growth timelines, CSV export | ✗ Basic performance tracking implied but not detailed |
| Follower growth tracking | ✓ Detailed tracking and best times to post | ✗ Not specified |
| Saved-post analysis | ✓ Keyword and author filters, historical collection | ✗ No analysis tools |
| Team analytics | ✓ Across multiple profiles in Business plan | ✗ Support for teams but no detailed analytics |
Collaboration & Agency Features
| Feature | AuthoredUp | Phantomwriter |
|---|---|---|
| Multiple profiles | ✓ Support for multiple LinkedIn company pages and sub-accounts | ✓ Support for teams and agencies with multiple clients |
| Draft collaboration | ✓ Team member collaboration on drafts | ✗ No collaboration on drafts |
| Organization management | ✓ Centralized control for teams and agencies | ✗ Basic multi-client support |
| Custom plans for agencies | ✓ Custom Growth Plan with onboarding | ✗ Pro plan for teams/agencies |
Integrations & Other
| Feature | AuthoredUp | Phantomwriter |
|---|---|---|
| CSV export | ✓ For saved-post analysis | ✗ Not specified |
| Audience analysis | ✗ Post-focused analytics | ✓ Industry, competitors, ICP analysis |
| Privacy and hosting | ✓ Strong privacy, EU hosting | ✗ Not detailed |
Pricing Comparison
AuthoredUp offers flexible pricing starting at $12.46/month per profile (yearly Business), ideal for scaling teams, while Phantomwriter starts at $49/month for individuals with a focus on AI automation. AuthoredUp provides better value for manual creators and teams, whereas Phantomwriter's higher cost reflects its AI-driven autopilot features.
AuthoredUp
Individual (Monthly)
$19.95/month
Solo creators managing one profile
- 1 LinkedIn profile connection
- Full editor with text styling, bullet points, emojis, and preview
- Full Chrome extension and web platform access
- Unlimited drafts, snippets, and company pages
- 300+ hooks and post endings templates
- 1‑click post reuse from historical content
- Content analytics for posts and profile performance
Business (Monthly)
$14.95/month per profile
Teams and agencies with multiple profiles
- Minimum 3 LinkedIn profiles
- Everything in Individual plan
- Connect and manage multiple profiles
- Sub‑accounts for team members and clients
- Organization management
- Team analytics across profiles
- Draft collaboration
Individual (Yearly)
$16.63/month
Committed solo users seeking savings
- 1 LinkedIn profile
- Billed at $199.50 per year
- Full editor and preview
- Unlimited drafts and snippets
- 300+ hooks and endings
- Content analytics
Business (Yearly)
$12.46/month per profile
Scaling teams with long-term plans
- Minimum 3 profiles
- Billed at $149.50 per profile per year
- Multi‑profile management
- Sub‑accounts and organization tools
- Team analytics and collaboration
Custom Growth Plan
Custom
Large agencies needing tailored support
- Personalized onboarding
- Dedicated training
- Flexible invoicing
- Custom features based on needs
Phantomwriter
Standard
$49/month
Individuals or small users needing AI posts
- 40 Monthly Posts
- Idea Generation
- Unlimited Regeneration
- Any Language
- Lead Magnet Creator
- Content Calendar
- For one LinkedIn account
Pro
$200/month
Teams and agencies scaling AI content
- Unlimited Monthly Posts
- Idea Generation
- Unlimited Regeneration
- Any Language
- Lead Magnet Creator
- Content Calendar
- For teams or agencies with multiple clients
Feature Deep Dive
Content Creation Capabilities
AuthoredUp
Strengths
- Rich editor with formatting, readability checks, and LinkedIn preview
- Unlimited drafts, snippets, and 300+ templates for inspiration
- Historical post collection for reuse and pattern analysis
- Focus on user-driven creation with reusable elements
- Chrome extension for seamless in-platform editing
Workflow
Save ideas as snippets → Use templates/hooks → Edit in rich editor → Preview and publish
Phantomwriter
Strengths
- AI ghostwriter for full, engaging posts based on audience analysis
- Idea generation tailored to industry/competitors/ICP
- 100% AI-undetectable content with unlimited regeneration
- Support for any language and lead magnet creation
- Three-step process: analyze, generate, schedule
Workflow
Input audience details → Generate ideas/posts → Regenerate as needed → Schedule on autopilot
AuthoredUp shines for hands-on creators needing a powerful editor and reusable assets, offering control and depth without AI. Phantomwriter is superior for automation, generating high-quality, undetectable content quickly with minimal input. Choose AuthoredUp for customization, Phantomwriter for speed and consistency.
Scheduling & Automation
AuthoredUp
Strengths
- Centralized content calendar with filters by type/account/tags
- Support for scheduling across multiple profiles
- Manual but reliable posting with preview
Limitations
- No AI or autopilot automation
- Requires active management for consistency
Phantomwriter
Strengths
- Content calendar integrated with AI generation
- Autopilot mode for consistent, hands-off posting
- Unlimited posts in Pro for scaling
- Idea-to-post automation reduces planning time
Limitations
- Post limits in Standard (40/month)
- Less flexibility for manual adjustments
Phantomwriter leads in automation with its AI-driven autopilot, ideal for busy users wanting set-it-and-forget-it posting. AuthoredUp offers a solid calendar for organized manual scheduling but lacks automation. For effortless consistency, Phantomwriter wins; for controlled planning, AuthoredUp is better.
Analytics & Reporting
AuthoredUp
Strengths
- In-depth metrics: impressions, engagement, growth timelines
- Follower tracking and best-time recommendations
- Posts table with filters, saved-post analysis, CSV export
- Historical insights for repurposing top content
- Team-level analytics in Business plans
Limitations
- No AI-powered insights
- Focused on post/profile data, not audience
Phantomwriter
Strengths
- Basic performance tracking for generated posts
- Implied insights from audience analysis
- Support for monitoring autopilot results
Limitations
- No detailed analytics or export options
- Lacks depth in engagement and growth tracking
- No team reporting
AuthoredUp provides comprehensive, exportable analytics tailored to LinkedIn performance, enabling data-driven improvements. Phantomwriter offers minimal tracking, sufficient for basic autopilot monitoring but not advanced analysis. For uncovering patterns and optimizing, AuthoredUp is the clear choice.
Use Case Comparison
Solo LinkedIn Creator
AuthoredUp 🏆
Excellent
Unlimited drafts, rich editor, and templates empower consistent, high-quality posting without limits.
Best Plan: Individual Yearly ($16.63/month)
Score: 9/10
Phantomwriter
Good
AI generation speeds up creation, but post limits may constrain frequent posters.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 7/10
B2B Marketer Focused on LinkedIn
AuthoredUp 🏆
Excellent
Deep analytics and post reuse help refine B2B content strategies effectively.
Best Plan: Business Yearly ($12.46/month per profile)
Score: 10/10
Phantomwriter
Good
Audience analysis aids ICP targeting, but lacks analytics depth for strategy.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 6/10
Building Personal Brand on LinkedIn
AuthoredUp
Excellent
Editor and historical insights support authentic, evolving personal content.
Best Plan: Individual Monthly ($19.95/month)
Score: 9/10
Phantomwriter
Excellent
AI ghostwriting maintains consistent voice for brand growth on autopilot.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 8/10
Ghostwriting Agency Managing Clients
AuthoredUp
Good
Sub-accounts and collaboration suit client management, but no AI for efficiency.
Best Plan: Business Yearly ($12.46/month per profile)
Score: 7/10
Phantomwriter 🏆
Excellent
Pro plan supports multiple clients with unlimited AI posts, replacing human writers.
Best Plan: Pro ($200/month)
Score: 9/10
Sales Team Using LinkedIn for Pipeline
AuthoredUp 🏆
Good
Analytics for best times and engagement help optimize selling posts.
Best Plan: Business Monthly ($14.95/month per profile)
Score: 7/10
Phantomwriter
Fair
Lead magnet creator aids capture, but no deep sales analytics.
Best Plan: Pro ($200/month)
Score: 5/10
Consultant Repurposing Winning Content
AuthoredUp 🏆
Excellent
Historical posts and reuse suggestions perfect for repurposing top performers.
Best Plan: Individual Yearly ($16.63/month)
Score: 10/10
Phantomwriter
Fair
Regeneration helps vary content, but no historical analysis.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 4/10
Budget-Conscious Solopreneur
AuthoredUp 🏆
Excellent
Low starting price with unlimited features offers great value.
Best Plan: Business Yearly ($12.46/month)
Score: 9/10
Phantomwriter
Poor
$49/month entry is steep for basics, with post limits.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 3/10
Marketer Targeting Multiple Languages
AuthoredUp
Fair
English-focused, no multi-language tools.
Best Plan: Individual ($19.95/month)
Score: 4/10
Phantomwriter 🏆
Excellent
Any language support enables global content creation.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 9/10
In-House Team for Personal Branding
AuthoredUp 🏆
Excellent
Multi-profile support and draft collaboration ideal for teams.
Best Plan: Business Yearly ($12.46/month per profile)
Score: 9/10
Phantomwriter
Good
Pro for teams, but limited collaboration.
Best Plan: Pro ($200/month)
Score: 6/10
User Preferring AI Autopilot
AuthoredUp
Poor
No AI, manual process throughout.
Best Plan: Not ideal
Score: 2/10
Phantomwriter 🏆
Excellent
Full AI workflow from ideas to posting.
Best Plan: Pro ($200/month)
Score: 10/10
User Focused on Data-Driven Optimization
AuthoredUp 🏆
Excellent
Advanced analytics, filters, and exports for deep insights.
Best Plan: Business ($14.95/month per profile)
Score: 10/10
Phantomwriter
Fair
Basic tracking, no advanced tools.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 3/10
Consultant Relying on LinkedIn Leads
AuthoredUp
Good
Analytics help optimize for engagement, indirect lead support.
Best Plan: Individual ($19.95/month)
Score: 7/10
Phantomwriter 🏆
Good
Lead magnet creator directly aids capture.
Best Plan: Standard ($49/month)
Score: 8/10
Pros and Cons
AuthoredUp
Pros
- Purpose-built for LinkedIn with tailored editor and preview
- Unlimited drafts, snippets, and templates streamline ideation
- Deep analytics with CSV export and historical reuse
- Supports multiple profiles and team collaboration
- Affordable per-profile pricing, especially yearly
- Strong privacy with EU hosting and Chrome integration
- Ideal for studying and repurposing winning content
Cons
- No native AI for post generation
- Interface may overwhelm beginners
- Chrome-dependent, limiting other browsers
- Per-profile pricing scales for teams
- LinkedIn-only, no multi-platform
- No free trial or money-back guarantee
Phantomwriter
Pros
- AI ghostwriting creates undetectable, high-quality posts
- Autopilot scheduling for consistent brand growth
- Audience analysis and idea generation reduce planning
- Unlimited regeneration and any-language support
- Lead magnet creator enhances funnel strategy
- Pro plan scales for teams/agencies
- Testimonials highlight efficiency for ghostwriters
Cons
- Higher starting price with post limits in Standard
- Narrow analytics, no deep insights or exports
- Limited collaboration beyond multi-client access
- No manual editor for fine control
- Transparency issues on refunds and yearly pricing
- All testimonials self-hosted, no third-party scores
- Heavier workflow for occasional users
Final Verdict
AuthoredUp and Phantomwriter are both LinkedIn specialists, but diverge in approach: AuthoredUp is a creator's studio emphasizing manual tools, analytics, and collaboration for strategic content. Phantomwriter is an AI autopilot for ghostwriting, ideal for automated, low-effort posting. AuthoredUp suits data-driven users; Phantomwriter fits time-strapped automators.
Select AuthoredUp for comprehensive creation and insights at a lower cost, especially if manual control and analytics drive your strategy. Opt for Phantomwriter if AI automation and speed are priorities, despite higher pricing. For hybrid needs, use Phantomwriter for generation and AuthoredUp for editing/analytics.
Overall Scores
AuthoredUp
Content Creation: 10/10
Phantomwriter
Content Creation: 6/10
Other Comparisons
Explore more tool comparisons to help you make the best decision:
